Flag Icon

Bay Area’s Most Trusted Cash House Buyers Since 2000

1031 Exchanges for Bay Area Landlords, Including California's Clawback

A 1031 exchange lets a Bay Area landlord sell a rental and defer federal and California tax on the gain by buying other real property held for business or rental use. You have 45 days to identify the replacement and 180 days to close on it. A qualified intermediary holds the sale money in between.

The tax is put off until you sell in a taxable sale. If the replacement property is outside California, the state keeps its claim on the gain from the Bay Area sale and expects a form from you every year until that gain is taxed.

This is general information, not tax or legal advice. The rules turn on details, so talk to a California tax adviser or real estate attorney before you list or sign anything.

What is a 1031 exchange?

It is a swap under section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code: you trade real property used in a business or held for investment for other real property held the same way, and no gain is recognized. Most landlords do it as a deferred exchange: sell first, buy later.

Since 2018 the federal rule covers real property only. The IRS says real property held primarily for sale still doesn't qualify, and neither does your own home. Real property in the United States is not like-kind to real property abroad.

California follows the federal rule. The Franchise Tax Board says state law conforms to the Internal Revenue Code as of January 1, 2025, and that California like-kind exchanges are limited to real property.

The new property takes over the old one's basis. Section 1031 sets the replacement's basis at the basis of the property you gave up, adjusted for cash and any gain recognized. If you also receive cash or other property, called boot, gain is taxed up to that amount.

If you're selling a duplex or a fourplex, our guide to selling a multi-family property in the Bay Area covers the sale itself.

What are the 45-day and 180-day deadlines?

You have 45 days from the day you transfer the old property to identify replacements in writing. You must receive the replacement within 180 days, or by your tax return's due date with extensions if that comes first.

  • Day 0: The rental closes and the intermediary receives the sale money.
  • Day 45: By midnight, you sign a written identification and deliver it to the intermediary or another party to the exchange. Describe each property clearly, by street address or legal description.
  • Day 180: By midnight, you close on the replacement. For a sale late in the year, the return's due date can come first; an extension can restore the full 180 days.

The regulations limit how many properties you can name. You can name up to three of any value, or any number whose combined value is no more than 200 percent of the property you sold. Name more than that and the identification counts only if you buy at least 95 percent of the value you named.

The deadlines are fixed. A replacement identified after day 45 is treated as not like-kind.

What is California's clawback, and what is Form 3840?

California keeps a claim on the gain from a California property even after you exchange into property in another state. Form FTB 3840 is the yearly information return that tracks that deferred gain until it is taxed.

The FTB instructions say the source of gain from California property is set when the gain is realized, and stays California-source whenever it is recognized. So when you later sell the out-of-state replacement in a taxable sale, California taxes its share. That is true even if you moved away years before. This is the rule people call the clawback.

Start Fresh

Don’t let your house hold you back

Revenue and Taxation Code section 18032 requires the yearly return for exchanges in taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2014. The FTB says every taxpayer who exchanges California real property for property outside California files Form 3840, whatever their residence. You file for the year of the exchange and each later year, generally until the deferred gain is recognized. If you don't file the form or a return, the FTB can estimate your income and assess tax, penalties and interest.

Here is a worked example with made-up figures. Say you bought an Oakland fourplex for $500,000 and claimed $250,000 of depreciation over the years, so your adjusted basis is $250,000. You sell it for $1,400,000.

  • Gain realized: $1,400,000 minus $250,000 is $1,150,000, before selling costs.
  • Replacement: You buy a $1,600,000 building in another state with all the sale money plus $200,000 more. No cash comes back to you, so no gain is recognized.
  • New basis: $250,000 carried over plus the $200,000 you added is $450,000.
  • Form 3840: The $1,150,000 is California-source deferred gain. You report it on the form every year until a taxable sale.

Your adviser figures the tax on each step; selling costs and other details change these numbers.

Can you do a 1031 exchange when you sell to a cash buyer?

Yes. A cash buyer pays into escrow like any other buyer, and escrow sends the sale money to your intermediary instead of to you.

The regulations let you assign your rights in the sale contract to the intermediary. All parties to the contract must get written notice of the assignment on or before closing. Tell the buyer and the escrow holder you plan an exchange when you sign, so the paperwork is ready.

A fixed closing date helps with the clock. The 45 days start when the rental closes, so knowing that day lets you line up replacement properties before you start.

We buy rentals with tenants in place, so you don't need to empty the building first. Our page on selling a house with tenants explains how. We can make an offer within 24 hours. We can close in as little as 7 days when the title is clear; 30 to 60 days is typical.

We are not tax advisers and don't set up exchanges. Your intermediary and tax adviser run the exchange.

What counts as like-kind property?

Almost any real property in the United States held for business or rental use is like-kind to any other. A Berkeley duplex can be exchanged for land, a commercial building or a rental house in another state.

The IRS lists buildings, land and rental property as examples. An exchange of city property for farm property, or improved property for unimproved property, qualifies. So does real estate exchanged for a lease of 30 years or longer.

What doesn't qualify:

  • Your own home: Real property used for personal purposes is excluded.
  • Property held mainly for sale: Houses bought to fix and resell don't qualify.
  • Property abroad: U.S. and foreign real property are not like-kind.
  • Furniture and equipment: Since 2018, personal property isn't covered. Any you receive in the deal counts as boot.

Both properties have to be held for business or rental use, and the IRS looks at how you use them.

When is paying the tax simpler than exchanging?

For some tired landlords, paying the tax is simpler. An exchange keeps you a landlord, now of a new building, often far from home, with a form due to California every year if it is out of state.

Deferring tax on a $1,150,000 gain keeps a lot of money working. The exchange also asks you to find, inspect and close on a replacement in 180 days, pay an intermediary, and take on new tenants and repairs. If you wanted out of being a landlord, a replacement building can feel like more of the same.

A taxable sale is simpler to run. Escrow usually withholds California tax at closing: 3 1/3 percent of the sales price unless an exemption applies or you choose the alternative calculation. On $1,400,000 at the FTB's .0333 rate, that is $46,620. You claim it as a credit on your California return.

A deferred exchange is exempt from that withholding at the time of the sale. If the exchange fails, the intermediary withholds 3 1/3 percent then.

Ask your adviser to run both cases with your basis, depreciation and income. If paying the tax wins, our page on selling a house as-is in California covers selling without repairs.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a qualified intermediary?

For a deferred exchange, you almost always need one. If you actually or constructively receive the sale money before you get the replacement, the IRS treats the deal as a sale and the gain is taxable. A qualified intermediary is a safe harbor against that. It can't be you or a disqualified person, which includes anyone who was your agent, attorney, accountant or real estate broker in the two years before the sale, apart from routine escrow or title work.

Can I exchange into a property in another state?

Yes, any real property in the United States held for business or rental use can replace a Bay Area rental. California still taxes the gain from the California property when you later sell the replacement in a taxable sale, wherever you live then. Until that happens, you file Form FTB 3840 with the Franchise Tax Board every year. A separate form is filed for each such exchange, so keep the paperwork in one place.

What happens to depreciation recapture?

It is deferred along with the rest of the gain. The replacement takes over your old basis, so the depreciation you claimed stays built into the numbers. The IRS calls the part of a real property gain that comes from depreciation unrecaptured section 1250 gain. It is taxed when you sell the replacement in a taxable sale. Cash or other boot can make some of it taxable sooner.

Can I live in the replacement property?

Not for the first two years if you want the IRS safe harbor. Under Revenue Procedure 2008-16, the IRS won't challenge a dwelling if you own it for 24 months after the exchange. In each of those years, you rent it at a fair rent for 14 days or more and limit personal use to 14 days or 10 percent of the rented days, whichever is greater. A later home-sale exclusion also waits five years from the exchange.

What if I miss the 45-day deadline?

The exchange fails and the sale becomes taxable. A property not identified by midnight on day 45 is treated as not like-kind. If you identified nothing, the regulations let the intermediary release your money after day 45. For California property, the intermediary then withholds 3 1/3 percent of the sales price. Talk to your tax adviser about the year the gain is reported.

Does a 1031 work for an inherited rental?

It can, but there is often little gain to defer. IRS Publication 551 sets the basis of inherited property at its fair market value on the date of death, or the alternate valuation date if the estate uses it. A rental sold soon after a parent's death may show almost no gain, so a plain sale can be the simpler path. Our page on selling an inherited house covers estate sales.

When you're ready

If you're weighing an exchange against a plain sale, a written offer and a firm closing date can help your adviser run the numbers. See how we buy rentals on our selling a house with tenants page, send us a message, or call (510) 283-9871.

Sources

Founder & Real Estate Investor

John Kirshenboim is the founder of John Buys Bay Area Houses, a trusted home buying company helping homeowners sell their properties quickly and hassle-free. With years of experience in real estate investing, John has helped hundreds of families navigate challenging situations including inherited properties, foreclosures, and homes in need of repairs. His mission is to provide fair cash offers and a stress-free selling experience for homeowners across the region.

Start Fresh

Don’t let your house hold you back

Helpful Insights for Homeowners

No thumbnailHome Selling

How We Calculate Our Cash Offer on a Bay Area House

Read More about How We Calculate Our Cash Offer on a Bay Area House
Living in Alameda, CA: A Guide to the Island City LifestyleLocal Insights

Living in Alameda CA: What the Island Is Actually Like

Read More about Living in Alameda CA: What the Island Is Actually Like
Selling a House with Mold in the Bay Area – A Homeowner’s GuideReasons to Sell

Can You Sell a House With Mold in the Bay Area?

Read More about Can You Sell a House With Mold in the Bay Area?